In partnership with
They said “better to have someone in the seat than nothing.” That’s a lie. The wrong seat costs 3 to 5 times more than the empty one.
Think Big Minute #26
Yahoo paid Henrique de Castro $58 million for 14 months of work. JCPenney lost $4.3 billion on Ron Johnson in 17 months.
Same math. Different zeros.
The cost of a bad hire is 3 to 5 times their salary by the time you account for delay, rework, and morale damage.
The “we’ll figure it out” hire is the most expensive number in your business.
Look at the hires the public got to watch in real time.
Marissa Mayer paid Henrique de Castro a reported $58 million severance for 14 months as Yahoo’s COO. He was hired to fix display ad revenue. Display revenue actually fell during his tenure.
HP hired Léo Apotheker from SAP in 2010. He spun off the PC division. Killed the TouchPad after one quarter. HP stock dropped 47% during his tenure. He was gone in 11 months. They paid him roughly $13M to leave.
Bob Nardelli left GE for Home Depot in 2000. Six years and $245M in compensation later, the board pushed him out with $210M in severance. Home Depot stock was flat the entire 6 years while Lowe’s doubled.
Ron Johnson moved from Apple to JCPenney in November 2011 to reinvent retail. He killed the coupon system 75% of customers were trained to use. Sales dropped 25% in his first full year. The board fired him 17 months later. JCPenney never recovered.
Stephen Elop took the CEO seat at Nokia in 2010. Wrote the famous “burning platform” memo. Killed the Symbian OS. Sold Nokia’s handset business to his former employer Microsoft in 2014 and walked away with around $25M.
Different industries. Different decades. Same broken hiring math.
This is what the cost looks like at a $100M scale. The exact same math runs at $100K.
Run the real number on a $100K hire that fails at month 7.
Their salary while underperforming: $58K.
Recruiter and onboarding: $5K to $25K.
4 to 6 months of delay on the work they should have been doing.
Cleanup of the work they did do, which usually takes another hire twice as long as starting from scratch would have taken.
Hiring cost on the replacement. Same recruiter fee. Same onboarding cycle.
The morale tax on the team that watched the bad hire underperform for months.
The customers, deals, or projects that quietly fell through during the period the seat was effectively empty.
The trust your A players lose in your judgment, which shows up later as them leaving for somewhere with a higher hiring bar.
Add it up.
You’re at $300K to $500K on what you thought was a $100K decision.
3 to 5x.
That’s the number nobody puts on the spreadsheet because nobody knows where to put it.
I’ve made this mistake at Legiit more than once.
Each time the pattern was identical. We needed help. We were behind. The “right candidate” wasn’t ready. The “good enough” candidate was available now.
I told myself we’d train them up. We’d figure it out. Better to have someone in the seat than nothing.
Each time it cost me more than waiting would have cost.
The bad hire wasn’t actually the problem.
The “we’ll figure it out” thinking that put them in the seat was the problem.
I had a hiring problem disguised as a workload problem. I solved the workload by adding a person. I didn’t solve the hiring problem until I started saying no to candidates I knew weren’t right, even when the team was screaming for help.
Here’s why business owners specifically are bad at this.
Most of us came up running our businesses lean. Doing every job ourselves. Wearing every hat. The whole posture is “do whatever it takes.”
That wires your brain to think the cost of an empty seat is higher than the cost of a wrong seat.
It’s the opposite. An empty seat costs you what it costs you. A wrong seat costs you 3 to 5x that, plus the time you’ll spend pretending it’s working before you finally fire them.
The empty seat is honest. The wrong seat is expensive in ways you don’t see until 6 months later.
Completely different math. The instinct that built your business in year 2 is the instinct quietly costing you hundreds of thousands by year 8.
Stop hiring to fill the seat.
Start hiring to fill the seat right.
The empty seat is cheaper than the wrong one.
Every single time.
Think Big.
1,000+ Proven ChatGPT Prompts That Help You Work 10X Faster
ChatGPT is insanely powerful.
But most people waste 90% of its potential by using it like Google.
These 1,000+ proven ChatGPT prompts fix that and help you work 10X faster.
Sign up for Superhuman AI and get:
1,000+ ready-to-use prompts to solve problems in minutes instead of hours—tested & used by 1M+ professionals
Superhuman AI newsletter (3 min daily) so you keep learning new AI tools & tutorials to stay ahead in your career—the prompts are just the beginning
The Fastest Way to Scale Creator Ads
Whitelisting and Spark Ads are your highest-ROI channel in 2026. minisocial is the fastest way to scale them — trusted by Our Place, Love Wellness, MadeGood, and Rocksbox. Brands using minisocial see creator ads outperform regular ads and at a lower cost per creator than in-house programs. Plus minisocial has no long-term commitments, and is known for their creator quality.
100 Genius Side Hustle Ideas
Don't wait. Sign up for The Hustle to unlock our side hustle database. Unlike generic "start a blog" advice, we've curated 100 actual business ideas with real earning potential, startup costs, and time requirements. Join 1.5M professionals getting smarter about business daily and launch your next money-making venture.